CO129-216 - Governor Sir Bowen - 1884 [5-6] — Page 134

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

14

15

133

3.

In explanation of the above minute of Council and of General Sargent's Memorandum attached to it, I would observe, that at first, on a prima facie view of the case, the Executive Council were inclined to advise compliance with the demand for extradition. But it was, of course, our duty before taking final and irrevocable action in a matter of such grave international importance and in which the lives of eleven men were at stake, to give full attention to the counter-statements and evidence adduced in favour of the prisoners, and to the allegations advanced by Bishop Raimondi and others that this was a case of a quarrel between two rival Chinese clans or factions, and that it should be regarded as of a political rather than of a criminal nature. The motives and proceedings of myself and of the Executive Council are fully stated in my despatch No. 358 of 1883, to which I beg leave to refer, and which should be read together with the present despatch.

Edit History

2026-05-24 13:42:36 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
14 15 133 3. In explanation of the above minute of Council and of General Sargent's Memorandum attached to it, I would observe, that at first, on a prima facie view of the case, the Executive Council were inclined to advise compliance with the demand for extradition. But it was, of course, our duty before taking final and irrevocable action in a matter of such grave international importance and in which the lives of eleven men were at stake, to give full attention to the counter-statements and evidence adduced in favour of the prisoners, and to the allegations advanced by Bishop Raimondi and others that this was a case of a quarrel between two rival Chinese clans or factions, and that it should be regarded as of a political rather than of a criminal nature. The motives and proceedings of myself and of the Executive Council are fully stated in my despatch No. 358 of 1883, to which I beg leave to refer, and which should be read together with the present despatch.
Baseline (Original)
14 15 133 3. In explanation of the above minute of Council and of General Sargent's Memorandum attached to it, I would observe, that and at first, an on a prima facie view of the ease, the Excentive Council were inclined to advise compliance with the demand for extradition. But it LUZJ of course, our duty before taking final and irrevocable action in a matter of such grave international importance and in which the lives eleven men overe at stake, to to give Your full attention to the counter- statements Sw statements and evidence adduced in favour of the prisoners, and to the alligation's advanced by Bishop i Raimendi and others that this was a case of a quarrel between two rival Chinese clans or factions, and that it should be regarded us of a a criminal. political rather than of a nature. The motives and proceedings of myself and of the Executive Council are fully stated in my..~ despatch 1: 358 of 1883, to which I 1978 beg leave to refer, and which should be read together with the present- despatek =
2026-05-24 13:42:36 · Baseline
View content

14

15

133

3.

In explanation of the

above minute of Council and of General Sargent's Memorandum attached to it, I would observe, that

and

at first, an

on a

prima facie view

of the ease, the Excentive Council

were inclined to advise compliance with the demand for extradition. But it

LUZJ

of course, our duty before taking final and irrevocable action in a matter of such grave international importance and in which the lives

eleven men overe at stake, to

to give

Your

full attention to the counter-

statements

Sw

statements and evidence adduced in

favour of the prisoners, and to the alligation's advanced by Bishop i Raimendi and others that this was

a case

of a quarrel between two

rival Chinese clans or

factions, and that it should be regarded us of a

a criminal.

political rather than

of a nature. The motives and proceedings

of myself and of the Executive Council are fully stated in my..~

despatch 1: 358 of 1883, to which I 1978 beg leave to refer, and which should be read together with the present-

despatek

=

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.